Last year at the Edinburgh Fringe, I saw Christopher Samuel Carroll perform his one-man show The Cadaver Palaver. It was a near-perfect piece of theatre, demonstrating his skill in physical storytelling, timing and imagination. I was excited to see what he would create with an ensemble.

His original work Crims draws on Australian criminal history, dark comedy and the visual style of German Expressionism. Carroll, who trained at the École Jacques Lecoq in Paris, brings an approach to storytelling that we don't often see on our local stages. This is something I welcome.

There are some excellent moments of physical performance. An opening scene in which the actors mime a game of pool is executed with remarkable precision. Later, a horse-racing sequence brings the ensemble together in a playful piece of choreography. These moments show what is possible when the performers tell the story through their bodies.

The cast of Marcel Cole, Gabriel Sinclair, Jack Shanahan, Miriam Slater, Petronella van Tienen and Piumi Wijesundara are outstanding. With most coming from dance and physical theatre backgrounds, it is impressive to see them take on such a text-heavy work. Each proves to be a strong actor, handling the demanding dialogue with skill and commitment. Their physical training is equally evident in the precision of the ensemble work, particularly the carefully choreographed movement of furniture, props and imagined objects.

Despite being promoted as physical theatre, however, Crims relies heavily on dialogue. Over two hours without an interval, the performers deliver an enormous amount of text, moving quickly between characters and scenes. I found myself wanting more time with these characters, more opportunity to understand their relationships and what was at stake.

The actors play multiple roles, but there is often little distinction in their voices or physical characterisation. This seems a deliberate directorial choice, although I wasn't sure what it brought to the storytelling. The pace and consistency of delivery made the narrative difficult to follow, and moments that might have carried emotional weight passed without much impact.

The live music offers another interesting possibility. A double bass, trumpet and accordion welcome the audience into the theatre, creating a lovely atmosphere before the performance begins. The musicians remain largely separate from the action, however, and I would have enjoyed seeing them become a more active part of the storytelling.

Having seen Carroll's skill in The Cadaver Palaver and other works, I was particularly interested in how he would approach this larger work. The strongest moments in Crims are those where the performers are given space to communicate through movement. I found myself wishing there were more of them.

I appreciate Carroll's ambition to introduce audiences to different theatrical forms. We need artists willing to experiment, challenge convention and take risks. But I also believe that beyond the exploration of form lies the question of what we hope to communicate.

Theatre has the potential to change the world, even in small ways. It can shift a perspective, challenge an assumption or leave us seeing something differently.

Crims brings together a talented ensemble, moments of genuine invention and a director with a clear interest in expanding our theatrical language. While the storytelling didn't always reach me, the strongest moments remind us how much can be communicated without words. I would have loved to see that possibility explored further.

Event details

Bare Witness Theatre Company presents
Crims
by Christopher Samuel Carroll

Director Christopher Samuel Carroll

Venue: The Queanbeyan Performing Arts Centre | 253 Crawford St, Queanbeyan NSW
Dates: 19 – 22 November 2026
Tickets: $60 – $30
Bookings: theq.net.au

Most read Canberra reviews

  • MOUNTAIN | Melanie Lane
    MOUNTAIN | Melanie Lane
    MOUNTAIN is at its strongest in transformation: body into landscape, clothing into architecture, acoustic into electronic, individual into collective.
  • A Drag is Born | Edu Díaz
    A Drag is Born | Edu Díaz
    Full of surprises, humour and moments of genuine tenderness, this is a show that celebrates the joy of discovering and embracing who you are.
  • Crims | Bare Witness Theatre Company
    Crims | Bare Witness Theatre Company
    Crims brings together a talented ensemble, moments of genuine invention and a director with a clear interest in expanding our theatrical language.

More from this author